a bit of history....
CHIEF CHELSEA, F2154

April 9, 1947 - April 6, 1981
(copied from Sundance "500" International Newsletter dated January, 1992)
by
Mary P. Hare
Schuyler, Virginia

Back to FAHR Newsletter Articles

The December, 1991 Sundance Newsletter carried the story of Chief Chelsea. The story told of the false pedigree that has been attached to this leopard stallion. Mary P. Hare has graciously given further information regarding Chief Chelsea's real pedigree. Sundance makes every effort to provide information so you can correct your pedigrees and pass along to others the true pedigree of Chief Chelsea. Thank you Mary Hare for sharing a bit of the past and present.

Having read the "old" material on Chief Chelsea that you gleaned from the Jan Haddle material, old Appaloosa News, etc., I feel guilty that I have not kept the "Chelsea lovers" updated on more current discoveries about Chief Chelsea! I have been out of the Appaloosa activities for over a dozen years, and Chief Chelsea died in 1981, so I have neglected to publicize the newer information.

Chief Chelsea I was more than a "fan" of Chief Chelsea. I was the major researcher of his line and other leopard lines in the late 1960's. At one time, I even considered to start a "Chelsea Breeders Association" fashioned after the Toby Breeders, Red Eagle Breeders and the Sundance Breeders, but just did not have the time to get it off the ground. I also held the key to the Arab Toswirah Alkhar (March-April, 1991 SN) discovery (Ghost Wind Stallions) and helped tie up a lot of loose ends about the Desert Horse Ranch, in addition to the Chief Chelsea history. This is a brief update and bloodline on Chief Chelsea to reflect more accurate background information as we have available today.

Franklin Murray owned the Desert Horse Ranch in southern California. His cousin owned another ranch in Red Bluff, California. Murray traveled a lot and was well educated. His travels took him to Argentina where he purchased several leopards tracing back to the Don Region of Russia, around 1919. One was an original "Don Russia" mare name So Rayna, imported from Russia in 1916, and two of her leopard daughters. Carlos, who worked for the lady in Argentina, came to the U.S. with the horses, and stayed as a companion to Murray until the latter died in a train wreck. This is the same Desert Horse Ranch that George Long Grass sold the Ghost Wind stallion, Blue Hawk, to in 1901.

In 1943, Franklin Murray took three horses and Carlos to Saskatchewan, Canada. One of these horses was Desert Dancer, a tri-colored leopard sired by Desert Night, a black leopard who was sired by "Ro" (i.e. Pharoah), a son of Blue Hawk, Desert Night, was a full brother to Desert King, the sire of Arab Toswirah Alkhar, F2417. While in Canada, Murray became acquainted with a man named McCree, who lived near Fir Mountain. He bred Desert Dancer to McCree's dun leopard mare known simply as The McCree Leopard. She was sired by a black McCree Leopard (also known as Checkers) stallion. Fir Mountain was near McCord, Saskatchewan, Canada.

In 1947, the 'special colt' was born. "The little one with the many-colored spots" is how Carlos described him. Murray named him Dancer's Rainbow, and was to carry on for his sire, Desert Dancer. But that was not to be, because while Dancer's Rainbow was still with his mother, they and 12 other horses were stolen! Carlos promised Murray that he would find the men responsible for the rustling and bring the horses back. Carlos trailed them to Montana and lost them.

There were four men involved with the theft. According to my Montana sources, three of the men were well known to the Appaloosa world, but it would serve no purpose to name them in this article. Carlos was able to track down the card dealer, who met an untimely death. It is assumed that the card dealer got the horses over the Canadian border into Montana and the other three involved continued their southward trek into Texas, and later Oklahoma.

Back in 1966 at the National Appaloosa Show in Syracuse, New York, I asked Elvin Blevins if he knew anything about the origin of Chief Chelsea. He told me that the sire was a leopard with many colors, but his name could not be revealed. His mother was a dun leopard, and that he had seen the mare in Oklahoma with Chief Chelsea. The earliest pictures I have on Chief Chelsea were attached to his ApHC registration application. He must have been about two years old by his immature build. Later, when I became a National Director in 1972, I again broached the Chief Chelsea subject to Elvin Blevins, who denied his 1966 story, saying that the pedigree was correct, except that the sire would continue to remain nameless.

In the spring of 1953, Carlos happened upon the colt in Oklahoma. How did he know it was the same colt after six years? "I would know him anywhere, believe me." How can you be sure? Lots of leopards have more than one color of spots. "Ah yes, but not the same pattern! You see, he had many colors on his back and sides, but only the black spots on his neck and all his legs. No, this was the same horse, the special one Senior Murray loved." What was his name now? "The man in Oklahoma called him Chief." Who had him in Oklahoma? "A senior Roy Wood." Did you tell him about the colt? Yes, but he said I was mistaken. He said the colt's mother was Minnie Pearl, but that is a lie." How do you know this for sure? "I tell you but one more time, this was the same colt." End of conversation. This conversation can be documented as to time and date.

Chief Chelsea surfaced at the 1952 National Appaloosa Show held in Quincy, California. The stud book records show that he was bred by Cliff McMurtry, and owned by Roy Wood, Chelsea, Oklahoma. In 1952, Bill DuBois and Ted Dudley went to Oklahoma to buy some horses. They stopped in Chelsea for gas. The attendant, seeing their rig, suggested they stop by Roy Wood's spread to look over his Appaloosas. Although Bill had heard of Appaloosas, these were the first he'd seen. He was completely taken by those spots! But, alas, Roy Wood would not sell Chief Chelsea.

The following spring, Bill and his brother, Laurel, returned to Oklahoma and this time Roy Wood was more than willing to sell Chief Chelsea for $500. Since Carlos saw chief in the spring of 1953, is it only a coincidence that the sale then took place in this short span of time? The rumor in Oklahoma was that Chief Chelsea had died. It would seem that Roy Wood wanted people to think he had died, but instead, quickly shipped him out of the area to Indiana.

The rest of Chief Chelsea's life is a matter of record, with Gene and Betty Woodling purchasing him from the DuBois brothers in 1961. But, I'd like to add that when the Woodlings took him to the 15th National Appaloosa Show, held in Springfield, Illinois in 1962, a man came up near Chief Chelsea, disbelief on his face. Betty heard the man exclaim to himself, "It can't be. That's Chief Chelsea! There's not two like him! I'd know him anywhere!" This man was Elvin Blevins, and he made a positive identification after a span of eight years. He'd heard that the horse had died. So, if Elvin Blevins could identify him after eight years, it certainly stands to reason that Carlos could after only six years!

I hope the readers will accept this updated background on Chief Chelsea. Sometimes old ideas get stuck in your mind and newer ones can't wipe out the old ones. I have enough corroborating material on this, gathered from a number of reliable sources, so that it has changed my mind.

(SN Editor's note: Because of the coincidences of this updated information, because of the fine reputation of Mary Hare, because of the known information about Chief Chelsea along with the reputations of Cliff McMurtry and Roy Wood, the only conclusion is that Chief Chelsea, F2154, was formerly Dancer's Rainbow, foaled 1947 in Canada. Roy Wood was known as a story teller and was permanently barred from the ApHC after he submitted several false pedigrees on other horses and was caught. He then began the American Appaloosa Association as a private registry. It lasted only a few short years. It is a matter of record that Chief's first registered foal was in June, 1950. If he was foaled in 1948 as claimed by Roy Wood, Chief would have been 15 months old when he impregnated the mare. Generally, a young yearling's sperm is too immature at this age, but it is possible. Coupled with Wood's reputation, it is more than likely Chief was 27 months of age. The mystery about Chief Chelsea is no longer.)

(FAHR's Editor's Note: Sundance Newsletters are invaluable, as they chronicle many of the famous Foundation Appaloosa bloodlines. The Sundance philosophy of breeding Appaloosa to Appaloosa selected Foundation bloodlines should be practiced today, as our registry can attest. Without the old bloodline registries of which Sundance is the last, you would not see as many FAHR eligible Appaloosa horses today. Thank you Sundance and those that have and champion Sundance bred horses, and a special thanks to Ralph Cannon.)

Back to FAHR Newsletter Articles